can sag mill and ball mill have the same dimensions

SAG milling extends itself to many applications due to the range of mill sizes available. They can accomplish the same size reduction work as two or three stages of crushing and screening, a rod mill and some or all of the work done by a ball mill. SAG mills are also an optimum solution for wet grinding since crushing and screening in these ...

Figures 3a & 3b give the power for an autogenous mill. Figures 4a and 4b are for the same size mill with a ball charge of 6% of mill volume (290 lbs. per cubic foot). In the above example the power was calculated for a 30% volume. However, with the same sheets the power can be determined for any volumetric loading from 15% to 35%.

An analysis of normal and shear (tangential) energy distribution for spheres with the same size distribution (from top size of 180 mm down to 20 mm) as an industrial SAG mill was carried out by ...

8.3.2.2 Ball mills. The ball mill is a tumbling mill that uses steel balls as the grinding media. The length of the cylindrical shell is usually 1–1.5 times the shell diameter ( Figure 8.11). The feed can be dry, with less than 3% moisture to minimize ball coating, or slurry containing 20–40% water by weight.

the ball mill, but they can also be used as a one-stage grinder. The absence of, or reduction in the number of, balls means they can be less costly to operate than ball mills. SAG mills of over 40-foot diameter have been constructed. Like the ball mill, the AG/SAG mill will have a critical rotation speed above which grinding ceases. Mill motor ...

In this case, the SAG mill design can do that. In general, the SAG mill manufacturers will control the addition amount of medium such as steel ball at 2-8%, so that the capacity of semi SAG mill to process materials can be increased by 10-30%. The SAG mill liners wear will increase by 15% due to the impact of medium such as steel ball during ...

The difference between autogenous and SAG mills is, it uses balls to grind like ball grinding mill. SAG mills have built-in lifting plates inside the drum. When the drum rotates, the lifting plates lift the materials and the balls to the top and release them back to the surface.

1. SAG mill is the primary tool for grinding. SAG mill is used before the other mills. Ball mill is a secondary, and it is used after the SAG mill. 2. SAG mill breaks the raw material into pieces for the further grinding. Ball mill is used to grind …

Wet grinding is accomplished in a slurry of 50 to 80 percent solids. AG/SAG mills can accomplish the same size reduction work as two or three stages of crushing and screening, a rod mill, and some or all of the work of a ball mill. Because of the range of mill sizes available, AG/SAG milling can often be accomplished Grinding Circuit Design

SAG Mill Success—Start with the Basics. SAG mills are often flexible enough to accomplish the same size reduction provided. by two or three stages of crushing and screening, a rod mill, and some or all of the. work of a ball mill. With units available in ratings up to 35,000 hp, capable of supporting a grinding line that can output more than ...

In the ever-increasing quest for reduced mineral processing costs and increased throughput tonnages, there has been a worldwide move towards larger and larger mill sizes. As such, FL has supplied some of the world's largest horisontal grinding mills with ball mills up to 28ft in diameter (22MW) and SAG mills up to 40ft in diameter (28 MW).

The Effect of Grain Size on Ball Mill Work Index The Bond ball mill work index is the most commonly used comminution testwork procedure in the Millpower 2000 database, with more than double the number of results of the second most common (the combined drop-weight test methods). The ball mill work index is defined as "the kW-hr per ton to ...

SAG power draw survey tabulation. This LibreOffice spreadsheet contains the raw data used to create Table 1 and Table 2 of the paper "An updated data set for SAG mill power model calibration", presented at IMPC 2016 in Quebec City, Canada in September, 2016. Refer to the paper for the definitions and meanings of the different columns.

The results showed that the HPGR-ball mill circuit achieved a 21% reduction in energy consumption over the existing SAG-ball mill circuit at the same P80 grind size of 160 mircons (μm). At a grind of 80% passing 75 μm, the HPGR-stirred mill circuit showed a 34% reduction in …

Even the SAG ball charge needs to be adjusted based on the size and hardness of ore it's working on. Too many grinding balls can prematurely wear out the grinding balls themselves. Operating a mine mill requires balancing a dynamic set of tradeoffs.

Size. The ball size in a mill has a significant influence on the mill throughput and power consumption. Here the ball size refers to two aspects, one is the maximum ball size, and the other is the correct ball size ratio. · The size of the grinding media directly affects the …

Supplementing the ball mill media according to changes in ball mill current, grinding sound, output and quality during daily production. Generally, a warehouse can be used with 3-4 grade balls, and fine grinding bins can be 2-3 grades. Three types of ball mill grinding. Control the …

The mill product can either be finished size ready for processing or an intermediate size ready for final grinding in a rod mill ball mill or pebble mill AGSAG mills can accomplish the same size reduction work as two or three stages of crushing and screening a rod mill and some or all of the work of a ball mill. HPGR High Pressure Grinding Rolls

Lead Mentor: Brent Sullivan, Senior Metallurgist Challenge Description Mt Keith was originally designed as a 6 Mt/a concentrator in 1994. Subsequent expansions and upgrades have taken the nominal throughput to 10.5 Mt/a, however the circuit can rarely maintain a feed rate that matches that. Mill throughput is a key driver for maintaining profitability at Mt Keith because of the low head grade ...

SAG mill. SAG is an acronym for semi-autogenous grinding. SAG mills are autogenous mills that also use grinding balls like a ball mill. A SAG mill is usually a primary or first stage grinder. SAG mills use a ball charge of 8 to 21%. The largest SAG mill is 42' …

experience or laboratory tests before mill size can be determined. The required mill net power P kW ( = ton/hX kWh/ton) is obtained from. P = const. x c x q x nc x Li x Di2.5; where an approximate figure for the constant is 3.5 for rod mills, 4.0 for overflow ball or pebble mills and 4.5 for grate discharge ball or pebble mills.

ZMI supply a full range of Grinding Mills for the Mining Sector. The size from 8ft to 34ft,include the ball mill, SAG mill, AG mill and rod mill. All the equipment designed by the reputable design institute and through the FEA process. We also provide the grinding mill …

2.6.1 Ball size distribution in tumbling mills 37 2.6.2 Milling performance of a ball size distribution 40 2.7 Summary 41 Chapter 3 Experimental equipment and programme 43 3.1 Laboratory grinding mill configuration 43 3.2 Preparation of mono-size grinding media 44 3.3 Feed material preparation 46

Grinding is one of the most important and expensive steps of mineral processing. Therefore, different types of grinding mills such as rod mills, ball mills, semi-autogenous (SAG) mills and autogenous (AG) mills can be utilized for comminution of mineral ores [].Up to today, SAG mills and AG mills have been widely used to reduce operation costs and increase throughput.

Similar results have been seen consistently across all the surveys where this approach has been used, including circuits with AG mills, pebble mills, HPGR, stirred mills and ball mills with fine screens. Figure 2 - Comparison of the OWi and SSE75 of the SAG and ball mill for 10 surveys conducted on the same circuit at different times.

A change in quality of ore type and ore size (F80). These types of changes can lead to process upsets such as mill spills and/or power excursions in SAG mills, "centrifuging" in ball mills, etc. The constant need to adjust plant operation objectives because of frequent problems with

With high aspect ratio SAG mills total charge to ball charge ratio should be greater than 2 (up to 2.5) for a coarse mill feed (say F80 > 110 mm). If the mill feed size is fine, say 50 mm or 30 mm, then you are looking at a total charge to ball charge ratio of about 1.5-1.6.

Wet grinding is accomplished in a slurry of 50 to 80 percent solids. AG/SAG mills can accomplish the same size reduction work as two or three stages of crushing and screening, a rod mill, and some or all of the work of a ball mill. Because of the range of mill sizes available, AG/SAG milling can often be accomplished Grinding Circuit Design

The particle size curve of HPGR product is "non-standard" according to Bond's root-2 rule, meaning the transfer size for Bond calculations is "synthetic" (same as for SAG mills). The "microcracking" reported in HPGR product has the same effect as the non-standard particle size distribution, and both of these are simulated together by this two ...

Therefore, the null hypothesis for the Eagle study was tracers do not move through the ball mill at the same rate as coarse particles. Coarse Particles Take Twice as Long. At Eagle, the ball milling circuit starts with a crushing plant and ends with a 12.7-mm screen. "The ball mill is 3.20 m diameter and 4.88 m long," the study said.

Single-bin structure ball mill, which is mainly used for coarse grinding or primary grinding, has high efficiency. 2. Medium-long cylinder ball mill, that is L = 3D. 3. Long barrel mill: L≥4D, usually have 2-4 bins. The specific configuration of the ball mill …

For example, the SAG mill may have 10 MW of power draw available and the two ball mills each of 7.5 MW of power draw available for a total of ratio of 10:15 (1:1.5). The software uses the particular power model (Bond/Barratt, Morrell Mi, etc.) to determine what is the transfer size where the ratio of E SAG to E ball matches the ratio of mill ...

The crushed pebbles fall directly onto the SAG mill feed belt and return to the SAG mill. SAG mill product feeds two parallel ball mills of 6.6 m×11.1 m (internal diameter×length), each with a 9.7 MW twin pinion drive. The ball mills are operated at a ball charge volume of 30–32% and 78.5% critical speed.